Memorandum Opinion and Order

This suit challenges the constitutionality of West Virginia’s Ballot Order Statute, which mandates that ballots for partisan offices list first the party whose presidential candidate received the most votes in the last election. Following the parties’ bench trial, the Court must now weigh the extent to which the Statute burdens the plaintiffs’ First and Fourteenth Amendment rights against the state’s asserted interests. Finding the state’s interests insufficient to justify the burdens created by the Statute, the Court now declares the Ballot Order Statute unconstitutional, enjoins the defendants from enforcing it, and orders the defendants to implement a constitutional ballot ordering system for future elections, including the November 2020 general election.